Climate series, part 7
One return flight to Colombo emits about two tonnes of CO₂e, roughly a full year of a sustainable carbon budget. This essay measures what it would take to pay that back.
scroll ↓
You book a flight from London to Colombo. At checkout, a checkbox offers to make the flight carbon neutral for a few pounds.
This essay is about that checkbox. Part six covered what flying costs; this one asks what it would take to actually compensate for a flight. Not with credits, but in kind: real cuts, from an ordinary life, until the flight is covered.
Everything below is counted and sourced. Scroll distance does some of the arguing: the smaller the saving, the longer the scroll.
The bill
London to Colombo is 8,715 km great circle. The UK government's 2025 emission factor for a long-haul economy seat, including the extra warming from jet exhaust at altitude, is 0.11704 kg CO₂e per kilometre. Two legs:
2 × 8,715 × 0.11704 = 2,040 kg CO₂e.
That is the tank: two tonnes, almost exactly one year of a Paris-aligned 2-tonne carbon budget.
The rules
The aim is to fill it back up with real cuts, no credits. Every rung on the ladder is a change to an average UK life, priced with the same government factors as the flight.
Three attempts. An attempt can stack several cuts; the marks on the side of the tank keep count.
Attempt one · park the car
The biggest lever an ordinary household owns. A typical family car covers about 7,100 miles a year; taking the whole car off the road saves roughly 159 kg a month.
A full year without the car covers 94% of the flight. Paying it off completely takes about 13 months.
Attempt one · only your share
That counted the whole car against one seat. This series otherwise counts each person's own share of the household driving: 80 miles a week, about 93 kg a month.
On that basis, a full year of not driving covers 55% of the flight, and paying it off takes about 22 months.
Empty it
Thirteen months without the car, or nearly two years of your own driving, to pay for one holiday. Few people would do it.
Empty the tank. Second attempt: three serious cuts, stacked together.
Attempt two · give up meat
Vegetarian for a year. An average UK diet comes to about 2,000 kg CO₂e a year; a vegetarian one to about 1,400. Twelve months of it puts 600 kg in the tank.
Attempt two · replace the boiler
Swap the gas boiler for a heat pump. For an average home that saves about 1,450 kg a year; divided across the household, 615 kg per person. It costs several thousand pounds up front, but it repeats every year after.
Attempt two · the holiday not taken
Cancel the other trip. A London–Barcelona return is 289 kg.
The total: a vegetarian year, a new heating system and a holiday given up reach about three-quarters of one flight.
Empty it again
Still short. Empty the tank once more. Third attempt: the eight cuts people actually make, stacked together.
Attempt three · waste no food
A year without wasting food: every leftover eaten, nothing binned. Eliminating your share of the UK's avoidable household food waste is the largest everyday cut on the list.
Attempt three · one degree colder
The thermostat down one degree, all winter.
Attempt three · retire the tumble dryer
No tumble dryer for a year. Every load line-dried.
Attempt three · wash cold, wash less
Every wash at 30 degrees, and one load fewer a week, for a year. Note how far you have scrolled, and how little the level has moved.
Attempt three · the reusable cup
A reusable cup, every day: 250 coffees, no disposable cups.
Attempt three · kettle discipline
Boil only the water you need, all year.
Attempt three · the tote bag
No plastic bags for a year: about 150 refused. (A cotton tote needs 131 uses before it breaks even with the bags it replaces.)
Attempt three · unplug the phone
Finally, a year of phone charging, given up entirely. The level is still rising, barely.
The verdict
Everything on that list, done in full for a year, fills about a sixth of the tank.
(Plastic straws are not on the list. There is no published per-straw measurement small enough to be worth printing.)
The everyday cuts are not nothing. They are a different order of magnitude from a plane. The remaining option is to pay someone else.
Back at the booking screen, the checkbox has a price list. When British Airways launched in-flow offsetting in 2022, offsetting a long-haul economy return cost £7.66, around £11 per tonne. Across the voluntary carbon market as a whole, the average credit traded in 2024 cost $6.34 per tonne: about thirteen dollars for this flight.
The price is low because most cheap credits do not remove carbon. They promise avoided emissions: a forest that might have been cut down will not be, and the difference is sold as a credit. The tonne exists only relative to an estimate of what would otherwise have happened.
In January 2023, an investigation by the Guardian, Die Zeit and SourceMaterial examined the rainforest-protection credits approved by Verra, the market's largest certifier, and concluded that more than 90% were "phantom credits" representing no real reduction. It built on peer-reviewed work by West and colleagues (PNAS 2020, Science 2023) showing that projects had overstated the deforestation they prevented. Verra disputed the analysis, and parts of it remain contested, but the crediting methodology was retired the same year.
The market's own reform bodies broadly agree. The ICVCM's Core Carbon Principles (2023) set an integrity bar that only a small fraction of issued credits has met so far. The Oxford Offsetting Principles (2020, revised 2024) recommend cutting emissions first and, for what cannot be cut, buying durable removal: carbon physically taken out of the air and stored for centuries.
The price list, then, is not four prices for the same thing. It is two products: promises of avoided emissions, and actual removal.
Removing this flight's two tonnes through Frontier's portfolios costs roughly $900–1,100; through a direct-air-capture subscription, above $2,000. A typical return fare on the route is £600–900. Credible offsetting costs about as much as the ticket, and often more.
The reckoning
Suppose you did all of it: the vegetarian year, the heat pump, the cancelled trip, your share of the parked car, every everyday cut. The tank is full. The flight is paid for.
Except for one thing.
You were already overdrawn
An average UK life emits about 7.1 tonnes a year. A sustainable one is about 2. The difference, more than 5 tonnes a year before any flight is booked, is the standing emissions of an ordinary life: heating, food, goods, roads, services.
The cuts above were already needed here.
You can't spend the same cut twice
The whole ladder, about 3 tonnes of cuts, closes barely half of that gap. Counted against the flight instead, the gap stays open, and the flight still adds two tonnes on top of the 7.1. A cut can be spent once.
What the checkbox sells is the assumption that your life was at zero before you clicked it.
Offsetting a flight is not hard because the arithmetic is hard. It is hard because there is nothing spare to offset it with. The cuts are real, and worth making, once. The one reliable way to keep a flight's two tonnes out of the sky is not to fly.
The flight is priced tank-to-wake with the DESNZ 2025 "With RF" factor, which already includes the 8% great-circle uplift and a ×1.7 multiplier on CO₂ for non-CO₂ altitude effects. The car rung headline uses a typical car's mileage (DfT NTS 2024: 7,100 miles/year) and the DESNZ average-car tailpipe factor, with no fuel-supply-chain or manufacturing emissions; the aside uses this series' per-person 80 miles/week instead. Household savings (thermostat, dryer, washing, kettle) are per person, dividing Energy Saving Trust household figures by 2.36 occupants; where EST publishes pounds rather than kilograms, the conversion chain is documented in the claim register. Each attempt fills the same tank independently; the attempts are not cumulative. The 7.1-tonne UK figure is consumption-based fossil CO₂ (not CO₂e), a slight undercount next to the CO₂e cut figures. The reckoning uses the per-person car figure so all its bars share a per-person basis. Full working: the claim register in the site repository (tools/offset/research/).
Get new essays by email
No spam, unsubscribe anytime · or use the Atom feed