Notes & Tones · An interactive essay

The Loan
You'll (Maybe) Never Repay

What you borrow and what you repay are two nearly unrelated numbers.

Scroll to begin ↓

A UK student loan does not behave like the debt everyone else in your life talks about. There is no bailiff, no credit score, no minimum payment to miss. You do not repay a fixed sum on a schedule until it is gone. Instead you hand over a fixed slice of whatever you earn above a threshold, and after a set number of years, whatever is left is written off. The balance on your annual statement, the one that so reliably alarms people, is close to a work of fiction. For a large share of graduates it is never paid in full and never will be.

That makes it an income-contingent repayment, not an ordinary loan. If you earn nothing above the threshold, you pay nothing, however large the balance. If you earn a lot, you pay 9% of the excess (6% for a postgraduate loan) and you might clear it early, in which case the interest rate genuinely matters. But if you earn a middling amount, which describes most graduates, you pay the same fixed percentage every year until the clock runs out, the write-off wipes the rest, and the headline balance barely touches what you actually hand over. In that case the thing is not a loan at all. It is a graduate tax with an expiry date.

Which of those three graduates you are depends on your salary, your plan, and how the years play out, not on the number at the top of the statement. The tool below lets you see your own case: set your plan and your salary, and watch what you would really pay over a career.

01 What you'll actually pay

Pick your repayment plan, then set your loan balance, your starting salary, how fast you expect your pay to grow above inflation, and inflation itself. The payslip line shows this year's deduction: nothing below the threshold, then a fixed percentage of every pound above it. The curve underneath plots that same rule across all salaries, with the kink sitting exactly at your plan's threshold and a dot marking where you land. The verdict sentence and the lifetime chart then run the whole term year by year, so you can see whether you clear the loan or the write-off catches you first. Try the "double my loan" button last: for many graduates it changes the lifetime cost by almost nothing.

Plan:

Which plan are you on?

Your plan depends on where and when you studied, not on anything you chose. The one you pick above is highlighted below.

  • Plan 1. Undergraduate study in England or Wales that started before September 2012, plus most Northern Ireland loans.
  • Plan 2. Undergraduate study in England or Wales that started between September 2012 and July 2023.
  • Plan 4. Scottish student loans, funded by SAAS.
  • Plan 5. Undergraduate study in England that started in or after August 2023.
  • Postgraduate. A master's or doctoral loan in England or Wales, repaid on top of any undergraduate loan.
£45,000 borrowed
£30,000 a year
2% a year
3% a year

What each control does

  • Loan balance. The bigger it is, the more interest builds up each year, so the more there is to out-run.
  • Starting salary. You repay a percentage of everything above the threshold, so a higher salary means a bigger yearly contribution, and it sets which side of the break-even line you begin on.
  • Salary growth. How fast your pay rises above inflation, and so how quickly your repayments catch up with the interest.
  • Inflation (RPI). It sets the interest rate charged on your balance, but it also lifts your salary and, on most plans, the repayment threshold. Turning it up inflates every number at once; where a threshold is frozen, it pushes you over the line sooner.

Outstanding balance and total repaid over your career. Shaded years are when interest outruns what you repay, so the balance climbs even as you pay.

02 Pay it off early?

Sooner or later everyone with a balance asks the same question: shouldn't I just get rid of it? Perhaps with savings sitting in an account earning less than the loan charges. Perhaps with an ordinary bank loan at a lower rate. Both sound sensible, and both are sometimes right, but the answer runs through a gate that has nothing to do with interest rates.

The gate is the write-off. If your earnings put you on course to have part of the balance wiped, then some of the pounds on your statement are pounds you were never going to pay. Hand them over early, by any method, and you convert forgiven money into spent money. No savings rate, however feeble, makes that a good trade. This is why the left side of the chart below is so lopsided: for lower salaries, keeping your savings wins by tens of thousands, and it is not close.

Only past the gate does the rate race start. If you will definitely clear the loan, the comparison finally becomes the one people reach for first: the loan's interest rate against what your savings earn after tax (inside an ISA, or under the personal savings allowance, that is simply what they earn). Loan charging more than savings earn? Paying it off saves money. Savings earning more? Keep them, and let payroll do its slow work.

The bank loan almost never wins. For it to beat the other two options, its APR would have to undercut the student loan's interest rate, and unsecured lending rarely undercuts RPI-linked rates on Plans 1, 4 and 5; only the Postgraduate loan's RPI+3% is sometimes within reach. And the swap is worse than the rates suggest: a student loan stops charging you the moment your income stops, is wiped if you die or become disabled, and expires on schedule. A bank loan does none of those things. You would be trading an insured, conditional debt for a raw, unconditional one, and the insurance is usually worth more than any rate edge.

Set your savings rate and a bank APR below. The chart shows what you would be worth at the write-off date under each choice, across the whole salary range, so the tipping points are visible rather than asserted.

4% a year
6.5% a year

Everything else comes live from the tool above: plan, balance, salary, growth, inflation. The comparison assumes savings equal to your balance, so the question is exactly "should I spend this pot on the loan?"

What you'd be worth at the write-off date under each choice. Paying off with savings is the flat £0 line, the benchmark the others beat or don't. Where the lines cross, the best answer changes.

03 The rules can change

Everything above runs on the rules as they stand in 2026/27. It is worth being clear that those rules are policy, not contract. The government has changed the terms of existing loans before, mid-stream, and it can do so again. Some changes are already announced; others are, at the time of writing, live proposals sitting in front of ministers.

Already announced. The Plan 2 threshold rose to £29,385 in April 2026 and is then frozen for three years from April 2027, through to April 2030; the tool models this freeze. Interest on Plan 2 and the Postgraduate loan is capped at 6% for the 2026/27 academic year, a temporary measure while high RPI would otherwise have pushed the top rate to 7.1%. And the Plan 5 threshold stays at £25,000 until April 2027, after which it rises with RPI.

Under review. In July 2026 the Treasury Committee published a report titled, without much diplomacy, Student loans: Broken and unfair?, drawing on more than 52,000 responses from borrowers. It recommends reversing the 2027–2030 threshold freeze, scrapping RPI in favour of the lower CPI measure for calculating interest, and making future loans proper contracts so that terms cannot be changed on borrowers after the fact. These are recommendations, not law: a select committee cannot change anything by itself, and the government's response is still pending. The realistic moment for any of it to become policy is the Autumn Budget. If the freeze were reversed or CPI adopted, every affected number in this essay would move in borrowers' favour.

A new system for new students. From January 2027 the Lifelong Learning Entitlement replaces undergraduate student finance in England with a single four-year funding entitlement, usable in one go or in modules across a working life. Its loans repay on Plan 5 terms, so nothing in the tool changes; what changes is who joins which plan. Existing borrowers stay on their current plans regardless.

None of this alters the conditions of any existing loan today. But if your decision is close, particularly the pay-it-off-early question above, it is worth knowing that the terms you are weighing are the kind that get revised, and that the current direction of travel is towards softer ones.

04 Glossary

Plain-English definitions for the terms and acronyms used above.

RPI (Retail Prices Index)
A measure of inflation. In this tool it sets the interest added to your balance and, on most plans, how fast the repayment threshold and your salary rise each year.
CPI (Consumer Prices Index)
The other main measure of inflation, usually lower than RPI. The Treasury Committee has recommended student loan interest be calculated with CPI instead of RPI; as of this writing it is a proposal, not policy.
LLE (Lifelong Learning Entitlement)
From January 2027, England's new post-18 student finance system: a four-year funding entitlement usable across a working life, with loans repaid on Plan 5 terms. It affects new entrants only.
Repayment threshold
The salary above which you start repaying. You hand over a fixed percentage of what you earn above it, and nothing on what you earn below it. It is a salary figure, not a slice of the loan.
Income-contingent repayment
Repayment tied to what you earn rather than to the size of the debt: earn nothing above the threshold and you repay nothing, however large the balance.
Write-off
At the end of the plan's term, any balance still outstanding is cancelled and nothing more is owed.
Nominal and real terms
A nominal figure is the raw cash amount; "in real terms" means after stripping out inflation, i.e. measured in today's money.
Break-even salary
The salary at which a year's repayments exactly cover the interest added that year. Below it the balance grows; above it, it falls.
PAYE (Pay As You Earn)
The payroll system that deducts income tax and student-loan repayments automatically from your pay each month.
SAAS (Student Awards Agency Scotland)
The agency that funds Scottish student loans, which are repaid under Plan 4.
APR (Annual Percentage Rate)
The yearly cost of a bank loan, interest and mandatory fees combined. It is the number to compare against the student loan's interest rate.
Annuity (fixed-rate loan)
A loan repaid in equal instalments over a fixed term, each part interest and part principal. Ordinary bank loans work this way; student loans do not.
Opportunity cost
What the money would have earned elsewhere. Spending savings on the loan costs you the interest those savings would have gone on to earn.

05 The small print

A tool like this is only as honest as its assumptions, so here they are in full.

Figures and rules. All thresholds, rates, interest rules, and write-off terms are the 2026/27 values that took effect in April 2026, which superseded the 2025/26 figures. The plans cover the current England setup (Plans 1, 2, and 5, plus the Postgraduate loan) and Scotland's Plan 4, exactly as configured in the tool.

Approximations. Repayments are deducted monthly through payroll in real life; the engine works in whole years, so a live payslip may differ by a few pounds from the annual figure shown here. All money in the model is nominal, and the year loop runs the length of each plan's write-off term.

The write-off clock is counted as years from the first April after you graduate, which is when repayment normally begins. Some of the oldest Plan 1 cohorts also have an age-based write-off; those rules are ignored here.

The pay-it-off-early comparison ranks the three strategies by final wealth at the write-off date, with every strategy starting from a savings pot equal to the loan balance and all loan payments drawn from that pot. It compounds once a year; a pot driven negative keeps compounding at the same savings rate (a single-rate simplification). The savings rate you set is taken as after tax. The bank loan is a 10-year annual annuity at the APR you set; in practice banks rarely lend student-loan-sized sums unsecured, so treat that line as a best case. Only paying the whole balance at once is modelled; the Student Loans Company also accepts partial voluntary overpayments at any time, without penalty, which this version ignores.

Not modelled in this version. Repaying an undergraduate and a postgraduate loan at the same time (a combined 15%), overseas repayment thresholds, voluntary overpayments, and the timing differences that come with self-assessment rather than PAYE. There is also a temporary 6% interest cap for 2026/27 on Plan 2 and the Postgraduate loan that is not built into the engine. It only starts to bite once you drag the inflation slider above roughly 3%, so at high inflation settings the tool slightly overstates the interest on those two plans.

Sources (all accessed 2026-08-16): gov.uk, "Repaying your student loan: what you'll repay" and "Interest rates", for thresholds, repayment rates, the Plan 2 income-banded interest, and worked examples; the House of Commons Library briefing on student loan interest rates and repayment thresholds (CBP-10654); MoneySavingExpert's student loans repayment guide for write-off terms, the base-rate cap, and the 6% cap; the Institute for Fiscal Studies on Plan 2 lifetime repayment and write-off shares; and the Bank of England base rate of 3.75% (held 30 July 2026), used in the Plan 1 and Plan 4 interest cap. For the policy-pipeline section: the Treasury Committee report "Student loans: Broken and unfair?" (7 July 2026) for the freeze-reversal, CPI, and contractual-terms recommendations; the House of Commons Library briefing on the Lifelong Learning Entitlement (CBP-9756) for the January 2027 rollout and Plan 5 repayment terms; and Hansard for the 2026/27 6% interest cap announcement. Full details and the sourced constants live in the tool's research notes.