Emissions paths come from the IPCC scenario families known as SSPs (Shared Socioeconomic Pathways), plus Climate Action Tracker's current-policies estimate. Removal paths are carbon dioxide removal (CDR): pulling CO₂ back out of the air. The appendix explains both. 1 Gt is a billion tonnes.
Even the optimistic case doesn't close the gap
Set the removal dial to its most hopeful setting and the pattern holds. On the high and medium emission paths, the largest plausible amount of carbon dioxide removal (CDR), pulling CO₂ back out of the atmosphere, barely dents the gap. Against the 2°C budget under current policies it buys roughly eight years, and none of it rescues 1.5°C on its own. The only combination that comes back under the 1.5°C budget is deep cuts first, with removal as the last mile that pulls the remaining overshoot back down. Removal complements cuts. It cannot substitute for them.
The scale problem is stark. Novel, durable removal is measured in millions of tonnes a year today; to play the role these scenarios assign it, it has to grow roughly 1,300 times by 2050 (State of CDR).
A word on "carbon capture"
Most headlines about "carbon capture" are really about carbon capture and storage (CCS): catching CO₂ at a smokestack before it reaches the air. That is an avoided emission, not a removal, and it is a different thing from CDR. About 51 million tonnes a year are captured this way today (Global CCS Institute, 2024). It never appears in the removal band of this widget, because it does not take anything back out of the atmosphere. For context, the International Energy Agency (IEA) sketches CCS ambition of around 6 billion tonnes a year by 2050, but even fully realised that is emissions avoided at the source, not the atmospheric drawdown the budgets require.
Appendix: how the model works
This widget is a deliberately simple bookkeeping model. A few choices matter for reading it honestly.
1. Gross versus net: the double-count trap
The published Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) scenarios report net emissions. Ambitious pathways such as SSP1-1.9 already bake large amounts of removal into themselves; that assumed removal is how they manage to go negative late in the century. If this widget subtracted your chosen removal from those net numbers, removal would be counted twice. So the emission bands here are gross: the scenario's own built-in removal is added back, and the removal you pick with the dial is the only removal in the arithmetic. These gross reconstructions are illustrative, not quoted figures.
2. Keyframes and interpolation
The sources give anchor values at roughly 2020, 2050 and 2100. The curves between those anchors are straight-line interpolation, so mid-century values are illustrative rather than precise year-by-year projections.
3. The sink is removal only
The removal band counts carbon dioxide removal (CDR) alone. Point-source carbon capture and storage (CCS) never appears in it, for the reason set out in the callout above: it avoids emissions at the smokestack, it does not pull CO₂ back out of the air.
4. The budgets
The carbon budgets are counted from a 2020 baseline, to line up with where the trajectories start. The 500 Gt figure is the budget that gives a 50% chance of holding warming to 1.5°C. That number is scientifically contested: measured from 2025, credible estimates of the remaining 1.5°C budget span roughly 130 to 235 billion tonnes of CO₂. The 500 Gt figure used here is one defensible choice from a 2020 baseline, not a consensus number.
5. What the model leaves out
It ignores non-CO₂ climate forcings, the permanence and reversal risk of land-based removal, economic feasibility, and regional detail. The crossing years and return years in the verdict are order-of-magnitude reading aids, not forecasts.
Glossary
- CDR
- carbon dioxide removal: pulling CO₂ back out of the atmosphere (definition from the IPCC's sixth assessment report; deployment data from the State of CDR report and CDR.fyi).
- CCS
- carbon capture and storage: catching CO₂ at a smokestack before it enters the air, an avoided emission rather than a removal (Global CCS Institute).
- SSP
- Shared Socioeconomic Pathway: the IPCC's standard scenario families, running from SSP1-1.9 (deep cuts) to SSP5-8.5 (fossil-fuelled growth) (IPCC AR6 Working Group 1).
- BECCS
- bioenergy with carbon capture and storage: grow plants, burn them for energy, then bury the CO₂ (IPCC AR6 Working Group 3).
- DACCS
- direct air carbon capture and storage: machines that filter CO₂ straight from ambient air (IPCC AR6 Working Group 3).
- IPCC / AR6
- the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the UN's climate-science assessment body; AR6 is its sixth assessment report (2021 to 2023).
- CAT
- Climate Action Tracker, an independent project that scores real-world policy against the warming it would produce.
- IEA
- the International Energy Agency.
- GtCO₂ / MtCO₂
- billion and million tonnes of CO₂: the budget figures use gigatonnes (Gt), while today's durable removal totals are still measured in megatonnes (Mt).